More is possible with merchant services than simply creating yet another product for a financial institution’s business line. If payments, deposits, reporting and cash management work in unison, merchant services could become a component of a much bigger commercial banking relationship.
The difficult part is in figuring out how to structure the offering.
While one institution might desire the ability to provide card acceptance without taking on the risk and technological responsibility of being an acquirer, another might wish to exert more control over the transaction process. Other institutions fall somewhere in between.
No one-size-fits-all model exists for every financial institution when it comes to merchant services. There is a delicate balance of control, cost, risk, technology considerations, merchant needs and future strategies that must be carefully considered.
Key Takeaways
- Banks generally approach merchant services through referral relationships, white-label partnerships, or more deeply controlled acquiring models.
- The right structure depends on the bank’s resources, risk appetite, technology environment, commercial strategy, and desired level of control.
- Merchant pricing should be evaluated by model, including flat-rate, interchange-plus, and tiered pricing, rather than assuming that one type of provider always uses a particular structure.
- Integration with business checking, treasury management, lending, reporting, and other banking services can create a more connected experience for commercial customers.
- Risk management, merchant onboarding, technical support, payment security, reporting, and pricing transparency should all be evaluated before a bank launches or expands a program.
Why Do Merchant Services Matter to Banks?
Businesses have become accustomed to asking their financial partners for assistance with far more than deposits and lending. Accepting payments is an everyday process for retailers, restaurants, professional services companies, construction companies, medical facilities, online sellers, and thousands of other types of businesses.
It enables banks to be involved in one of the most common financial transactions made by their business clients.
By connecting payments to a business checking account, the merchant is able to receive settlement payments using the same financial services account that is used for payroll, paying vendors, lending, and cash management. In addition to being part of the financial process itself, payments become connected to the business’s finances.
For banks, merchant services represent additional fee revenue sources and provide additional opportunities to assist clients with other financial services such as treasury management, commercial lending, anti-fraud services, and other banking products.
The strategy becomes less about whether or not the bank offers merchant services and more about which parts of the merchant relationship a bank would like to hold.
What Is a Bank Merchant Services Program?
Merchant services program provides its customers with all necessary means in order to be able to process electronic payments.
It might comprise different methods of payment including card acceptance in person, online payments, mobile payments, virtual terminal, payment gateway, settlements and reporting, chargebacks handling, fraud control, recurring billing, and POS technology.
There are several entities that might take part in one transaction.
Processor is responsible for transaction routing and processing. Card networks provide the infrastructure and rules of operation that connect all participants of the transaction together. Card holder is represented by issuing bank while the merchant is represented by the acquiring side of the transaction.
Payment gateways are essential technology that helps to make transactions online and card-not-present transactions in general. It securely transfers the information about transaction from the merchant’s checkout system to the processing infrastructure.
Not all parts of the ecosystem necessarily should be provided by banks directly. That is why it is very important to choose a right merchant services program model.
What Are the Main Merchant Services Program Models for Banks?
Banks typically have three broad strategic options: referral programs, white-label partnerships, and more comprehensive in-house acquiring models.
The differences are largely about control.
Referral Programs
Referral is another simple way through which a bank can enter merchant services.
The bank refers its corporate clients to the merchant services provider, with the latter handling many processes such as underwriting, processing, technology, servicing, and payments.
It may be an ideal arrangement for a bank that would like to offer payment acceptance without committing huge capital resources towards technology.
However, the disadvantage of this approach is lack of control, whereby the merchant may only interact with the third party in most cases.
White-Label Merchant Services
The white-label relationship brings the bank one step closer to becoming the center of the experience.
Although the processing and technology will continue to be provided by the outside vendor, the merchant-facing system could run under the bank’s brand. This depends upon how much control the bank is willing to exert regarding pricing, onboarding, configuring products, generating reports, and providing customer support.
For banks seeking some form of middle-ground between outsourcing and developing their own acquiring platform, this may prove a good compromise.
The specific areas of responsibility differ greatly depending upon the provider and the contract negotiated, and the banks must know which side of the fence each of these areas falls on.
In-House Acquiring
The banks looking for ultimate control can also take care of the acquiring functions to a greater extent internally.
This will result in increased control over merchant underwriting, pricing, risk management, technology choices, customer management, and product management.
It involves much higher operational requirements as well.
All of these operations require proper payment infrastructure, people, regulation, anti-fraud measures, security procedures, merchant risk management, and all other required operations.
Therefore, the acquisition model with ultimate control is justified when it involves enough value to justify its higher cost.
How Do the Merchant Services Models Compare?
| Consideration | Referral Program | White-Label Partnership | In-House / Bank-Controlled Acquiring |
| Initial investment | Lower | Moderate | Highest |
| Speed to market | Generally fastest | Moderate | Generally longest |
| Brand control | Limited | High | Very high |
| Pricing control | Limited to moderate | Greater flexibility | Extensive control |
| Technology responsibility | Primarily provider | Shared | Primarily bank |
| Merchant risk exposure | Typically lower | Depends on agreement | Higher |
| Compliance workload | Primarily oversight | Shared responsibilities | Significant internal responsibility |
| Customer relationship | Shared with provider | More bank-centered | Bank-controlled |
| Best suited for | Institutions seeking a simpler entry point | Banks wanting stronger branding and control | Institutions with substantial payments expertise and infrastructure |
However, banks must view this chart as a strategic point of departure instead of a fixed formula since two organizations providing the same basic model can allocate their roles in an entirely different manner.
It is crucial to consider not only the label but the underlying contract too.
How Should a Bank Choose a Merchant Services Model?
It needs to start with the overall commercial strategy of the bank.
A bank which is more concerned about keeping the payment acceptance as part of its broader commercial relationships would be happy to do so through a referral process.
A bank which feels payments as an integral part of its commercial banking experience would want a white-label solution in order to get the increased exposure through its own brand name.
Banks looking at gaining tighter control need to evaluate whether the revenue from processing and the volume of merchants make it worthwhile to invest in the technology and people.
Risk management is yet another critical issue as there are various risks in merchant acquisition such as chargebacks, frauds, merchant failures, refunds, etc.
What Should a Merchant Services Product Set Include?
The right product mix depends on the businesses the bank serves.
- A neighborhood restaurant does not have the same payment needs as an accounting firm, e-commerce retailer, plumbing company, or medical practice.
- An in-person merchant may need EMV and contactless terminals, receipt printing, tip functionality, inventory tools, and integrated point-of-sale software.
- A field-service business may care more about mobile readers, invoicing, payment links, and the ability to accept payments at a customer’s location.
- Professional services firms may need recurring billing, virtual terminals, saved payment credentials, and invoice management.
- E-commerce merchants need payment gateways, checkout integrations, tokenization, fraud screening, digital wallet compatibility, and reliable card-not-present processing.
Instead of building one generic package, banks can evaluate merchant segments and design options around the workflows customers actually use.
How Should Banks Approach Merchant Services Pricing?
In particular, pricing is an aspect that should be considered due to the difficulty of determining the cost incurred when dealing with payment processing.
The available options for pricing include the use of flat rate pricing, interchange pricing, and tiered pricing.
No one particular pricing model can be attributed solely to the bank, the fintech company, or the processor.
Merchant Services Pricing Models
| Pricing Model | How It Works | Potential Advantages | Potential Considerations |
| Flat-rate pricing | Merchant pays a consistent percentage and sometimes a fixed amount per transaction | Simple to understand and forecast | May cost more for some merchants depending on transaction mix |
| Interchange-plus | Merchant pays underlying interchange and network costs plus an agreed processor markup | Provides greater visibility into processing costs | Statements may be more complex |
| Tiered pricing | Transactions are grouped into pricing categories such as qualified and non-qualified | Can appear simple at a high level | Tier classifications can make true processing costs harder to evaluate |
Pricing also needs to be considered beyond the stated transaction rate.
There could be additional costs such as gateway fees, monthly service fees, PCI fees, chargeback fees, hardware costs, minimum processing fees, or anything else based on the vendor.
Being upfront about fees is critical.
The banks that will make it easy for customers to figure out their cost of payments and not force them to read through a lengthy statement full of confusing fee names will gain customer satisfaction.
More volume merchants might need customized pricing as well.
What Role Do Risk, Compliance and Underwriting Play?
Merchant Services Risk Factors
The risks that come along with merchant services are quite different from risks associated with a regular deposit account.
There needs to be a defined process of evaluating the business for banks and merchant services firms alike before they board such businesses.
It includes business verification, ownership, estimation of transaction volume, average ticket size, industry risk, card not present, risk of fraud and chargebacks.
Some industries have higher risks than others and would therefore require more underwriting, reserves and monitoring.
Risk management should not be limited to the time of boarding.
Things could change in the future as the merchant begins to process more volume, have more refunds, chargebacks or even process transactions using a method different from its initial business.
All this can be achieved through continuous monitoring by the bank.
Security of payments cannot be neglected at any cost.
This includes compliance to PCI DSS requirements, tokenization, encryption, point-to-point encryption if necessary, secure payment pages, access controls, and fraud monitoring among others.
Where the responsibilities are outsourced, it would still be important for the banks to know what its partner is doing and what responsibilities remain on its side.
How Can Merchant Services Integrate With Other Banking Products?
This is where merchant services can add more value than merely the card processing solution.
A business might settle its cards in the same bank account that it pays salaries to its employees and to its suppliers/vendors. Treasuries products can help the client manage its liquidity. Loans products can take care of the need for working capital. Reports can give a more insightful view of the income and expenses.
Data on payments can also help understand the business operations of the customer if proper systems and permission are in place.
Some of the areas for integration could include consolidated reporting of transactions, reconciliations tools, visibility of settlements, treasury management dashboards and integration with accounting/enterprise system.
These integrations can enrich the core banking relationship by enabling businesses to have a more integrated view of payments, deposits, loans and cash management.
The objective should not only be to make it hard for the customer to move out. The idea should be to make the relationship so rich that there is enough reason for the client to remain.
What Should Banks Look for in Merchant Onboarding and Support?
An excellent merchant services plan can be undermined by a poorly conceived onboarding process.
Merchants will always prefer quick start-up times; however, speed must not compromise underwriting and risk control measures.
Banks should review the entire onboarding process from a merchant’s point of view.
Is the application easy to fill out? Is the information that the bank already has on record enough to eliminate duplicating work? How fast do they process typical applications? Are the equipment, gateways, and credentials sent in a timely manner? Whom does the merchant turn to in case of difficulties?
Banks have to pay special attention to technical support while selecting providers.
Banks should take into account support hours, escalation policy, equipment, gateways, and credentials support, response time, etc.
This aspect is very individual depending on the merchant type.
A bank that works with restaurants and e-commerce merchants would most likely require more extensive support than an institution working mainly with professional-service companies operating within regular office hours.
What Metrics Should Banks Use to Measure Program Performance?
The processed volume and fees are important, but they do not tell the whole story.
Merchants’ service should be analyzed by banks from two perspectives – as a payment product and as an element of the larger commercial offering.
Relevant performance metrics include active merchant account numbers, processed volume, net fee income, merchant attrition, chargebacks, adoption by the bank’s current business customer base, support trends, and number of merchant that use additional banking products.
Also, banks could look at time needed to activate new accounts, the percentage of abandoned onboarding process, which bundles of products are the most popular and successful migration from face-to-face to mobile to online channels.
Financial, operational, risk, and customer metrics in one dashboard would give banks a much more complete picture than just revenue.
What Trends Are Changing Bank Merchant Services?
There is a continuous trend of speeding up payments, making them more integrated and providing more flexible acceptance methods.
Banks are faced with expectations from merchants to process payments from customers on-premises, over the web, mobile devices, via subscription payments, and account-to-account.
Moreover, real-time payment capability creates new opportunities for transferring money and handling liquidity.
Embedded payments is yet another innovation in the industry. Software solutions for businesses, such as those that allow booking appointments, managing restaurants, running field services, and selling online, often include payments as an integral feature.
For banks, this implies both competition and collaboration potential.
When assessing potential merchant services platforms, banks have to evaluate API capabilities, integration possibilities, reporting tools, data portability, security, and whether the platform can accommodate new payments methods without replacing the entire technology suite.
How PayTech Trust Helps Financial Institutions Evaluate Merchant Services
Creating a merchant services program or enhancing an existing one involves much more than simply choosing a processor.
PayTech Trust assists banks and financial institutions with analyzing aspects of their payment acceptance and merchant services strategies and processes which impact them as well as their business customers.
This analysis may aid banks in realizing what areas benefit from having more control while what may benefit from having third parties involved and how merchant services relate to their overall business banking strategy.
What tools are available depends on the choice of processors, gateways, bank systems, contractual arrangements and scope of implementation. Find out more about PayTech Trust’s collaboration with financial institutions for payment processing and integration solutions.
Building a Merchant Services Program That Fits the Bank
While the ideal merchant services approach is not necessarily the one that provides banks with maximum control over the process, it certainly will be one that works for a specific institution.
For some banks, it might mean simply having a referral-based program, while others would do better with a white-label service, which would put the bank’s branding and relationships managers directly into the equation. Larger institutions with the volume of transactions, experience with processing payments and adequate technological resources will be able to go even further down that road.
The crucial point here is to make that choice consciously.
There is a list of criteria, including pricing, user experience, risk management, payments security, integrations capabilities, reporting, support, and scalability considerations that need to be analyzed carefully in order to decide on the approach.
The right merchant services program for banks can go far beyond mere payments acceptance solution for its customers. Payments will become an integral part of the overall financial picture and will provide businesses with an easier tool to manage cash flows.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a merchant services program for a bank?
Merchant Services is an arrangement where businesses can use a bank to accept and process electronic payments. Services provided vary from program to program but may include card processing, POS solutions, payment gateway services, mobile payments, virtual terminal, settlement reports, fraud protection, recurring payments, and chargeback handling.
Does a bank have to process merchant transactions itself?
No. Banks may refer clients to third party processors, engage in white-label arrangements, or take on a greater level of involvement in acquiring and processing. The right solution will depend on the approach taken by the bank.
What is the difference between a referral and white-label merchant services program?
With the referral program, the third party usually retains more control over the merchant’s experience once the initial referral is made. The white-label program involves a situation whereby the underlying provider can run the processing technology, but the program can appear to belong to the bank.
Which merchant services pricing model is best?
The pricing method that is the best for all merchants does not exist. The first method is the flat rate, which is easy to understand, and interchange-plus allows seeing the actual processing fees. Tiered pricing classifies the transactions according to pricing tiers. There are many aspects that can influence the choice of pricing method.
How should banks address merchant concerns about hidden fees?
The banks have the ability to simplify pricing by clearly stating the markup from processors, network fees, monthly costs, gateway fees, hardware costs, PCI fees, chargeback fees, among others. The clearer picture of the overall cost of making payments will minimize surprises.
What role does a business checking account play in merchant services?
The money from merchant settlements can also be transferred to the checking account, which enables customers to have more integration in relation to the payment process and other activities conducted by the bank. The combination of the aforementioned processes might lead to easier reconciliation for businesses.
Can community banks offer competitive merchant services?
Indeed. There is no need for the bank to invest into developing its processing capability in order to provide merchant services to its customers. The referral or white-label approach enables banks to utilize third-party solutions by leveraging their established customer base, services, lending, treasury services, and deposits.